George Hibbert [1757-1837], London; William Esdaile [1758-1837] (Lugt 2617), London; (sale, London, Christie's, 18-25 June 1840, lot 1178); John Postle Heseltine [1843-1929] (Lugt 1507), London; Henry Oppenheimer [1859-1932] (Lugt 1351), London; by descent to Eric Oppenheimer (sale, London, Christie's, 6 July 1976, lot 150); (Martyn Gregory, London); (sale, London, Christie's, 7 July 1981, lot 121); purchased by Ian Woodner, New York; by inheritance to his daughters, Andrea and Dian Woodner, New York, 1990.